A parent expresses their gratitude for your hard work by giving you a gift card to a popular restaurant. A few days later, the same parent emails you, requesting extra credit opportunities for their child, who is on the verge of receiving a lower grade than expected. You suspect that the gift may be an attempt to influence your grading decisions, but you also appreciate the parent’s gesture. Your school has clear policies regarding gifts and grade adjustments, but there is some gray area regarding what constitutes acceptable appreciation gifts. Ethical Dilemma: Do you accept the gift and consider the extra credit request, or do you decline and adhere to the school's policy on gifts and grading?
Discussion Topics:
- Balancing appreciation and policy
- How do you respond to gratitude in ways that maintain professionalism?
- Is it ever acceptable to accept gifts from families? Where should the line be drawn?
- Fairness in grading
- How do we ensure all students are treated equally when external pressures are applied?
- Does allowing extra credit after a gift—even with good intentions—compromise equity?
- The influence of perception
- How might your actions be interpreted by students, parents, colleagues, or administrators?
- Why does perception matter just as much as actual behavior in education ethics?
- Responding to parental pressure
- How can teachers maintain boundaries while keeping lines of communication open with families?
- What strategies can educators use when a parent oversteps?
- Clarity in policy
- Are your school’s policies around gifts and grading clear and actionable?
- What gray areas exist, and how might they be clarified for future situations?
- Maintaining professional trust
- How do decisions like these impact your reputation as a fair and ethical educator?
- How can you role-model integrity for students even when it’s uncomfortable?
- Proactive solutions
- What systems can schools implement to reduce ethical ambiguity around gifts?
- How can educators be supported in handling parent expectations without compromising ethics?
Download Simulation Overviews